FDIC Vice Chair knocks SEC's crypto accounting bulletin, saying it 'sharply departs' from current custodian practices
Quick Take FDIC Vice Chair Travis Hill also brought up the effect of SAB 121 on spot bitcoin exchange-traded funds that were approved by the SEC earlier this year. Lawmakers had said banks wouldn’t be able to be custodians for those ETFs because of the bulletin. The bulletin, released in March 2022, requires firms that custody crypto to record customer crypto holdings as liabilities on their balance sheets.
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Vice Chair Travis Hill sharply criticized the Securities and Exchange Commission's handling of a controversial crypto accounting guidance during a speech on Monday.
Hill, the FDIC's second-in-command, said that the SEC's Staff Accounting Bulletin 121, or SAB 121, diverges from current custodian practices. Released in March 2022, the bulletin requires firms that custody cryptocurrencies to record on their balance sheets their customers' crypto holdings as liabilities.
"This treatment sharply departs from how custodians account for all other assets held in custody, which are generally held off balance sheet and treated as the property of the customer, not the custodian," Hill said on Monday at an event hosted by the Mercatus Center about tokenization. Hill was nominated as a Republican to the FDIC in 2022.
The bulletin has drawn controversy over the past year over concerns in the crypto industry that it could prevent banks from custodying digital assets. Lawmakers advanced a resolution last month to rescind the bulletin after a Congressional watchdog said the SEC needed congressional approval before moving forward with SAB 121.
Hill also brought up the effect of SAB 121 on spot bitcoin exchange-traded funds that the SEC approved earlier this year. Lawmakers had said banks couldn't be custodians for those ETFs because of the bulletin.
"It is worth asking whether it is in the public interest for one crypto exchange to provide custody services for most of the market in approved bitcoin exchange traded products, while highly regulated banks are effectively excluded from the market," Hill said on Monday.
The SEC's definition of crypto is too broad and can include "tokenized versions of real-world assets."
"I think this is a clear example of why it is generally constructive for agencies to seek public comment before publishing major policy issuances," Hill said. "At a minimum, I believe it would be helpful to clarify that SAB 121 does not apply to the wider universe of tokenized assets beyond blockchain native assets."
More clarity needed
Hill said that regulators must also provide more clarity surrounding digital assets, blockchain, and distributed ledger technology.
"I appreciate the need for regulators to be deliberative and careful in approaching these issues," Hill said. "We should do our homework and make sure we understand the implications of new technologies that can reshape banking."
"There are significant downsides to the FDIC's current approach, which has contributed to a general public perception that the FDIC is closed for business if institutions are interested in anything related to blockchain or distributed ledger technology," Hill added.
Disclaimer: The content of this article solely reflects the author's opinion and does not represent the platform in any capacity. This article is not intended to serve as a reference for making investment decisions.
You may also like
XRPPERP now launched for USDC-M futures trading
Bitget has launched XRPPERP for futures trading with a maximum leverage of 75 on November 27, 2024 (UTC+8). Welcome to try futures trading via our official website (www.bitget.com) or Bitget APP. XRPUSDC-M perpetual futures: Parameters Details Listing time November 27, 2024 16:40 (UTC+8) Underlying
Bitcoin (BTC) Surges to New Heights Amidst Robust Capital Inflows
Bitcoin's price hits an all-time high of $93k, driven by $62.9 billion capital inflows, with ETFs playing a critical role in stabilizing the market.
Bitfarms Expands Board and Appoints Andrew J. Chang as Independent Director
Bitfarms announces board expansion to six members, appointing Andrew J. Chang as an independent director, following a special shareholder meeting. Key shareholder proposals were approved.
Pantera Bitcoin Fund Achieves 1,000x Milestone Amidst Market Surge
Pantera Bitcoin Fund reaches a significant 1,000x growth milestone, with post-election market dynamics further boosting its performance, according to Pantera Capital.